PP962
Analítico de Periódico
LEE, Edward, e outro
Do experts matter? : a study of the effect of musicologist testimony in music cases / Edward Lee, Andrew Moshirnia
University of Illinois Law Review, n.2 (2022), p.707-804
DIREITOS DE AUTOR / EUA, PROPRIEDADE INTELECTUAL, COPYRIGHT, ACÇÃO JUDICIAL, PERITOS, MÚSICA, TESTEMUNHO, JULGAMENTO
This Article presents the results of a behavioral experiment we conducted to identify what effect, if any, expert musicologist testimony has on jurors in a simulated music copyright lawsuit. Forensic musicologists are considered essential to deciding whether one song infringes the copyright of another song. But this conventional wisdom has never been tested or validated. Contrary to this accepted view, our study found that expert musicologists have little to no effect on jurors when presented as a battle of experts of the parties. However, a court-appointed expert had a significant effect on subjects who lacked training or knowledge in music. These findings call into serious question the current approach to expert testimony in music lawsuits. We consider several alternatives as possible reforms, including greater use of court-appointed experts, the courts’ exercise of a greater gatekeeping role in the dissection of the works at issue, or even the radical idea of excluding musicologist testimony at trial altogether.