PP.17.18.RFDUP
Analítico de Periódico
ANGEL, Carrasco Perera
"Eutopian strategies" : a review of the rule of abuse of rights / Angel Carrasco Perera
In: Revista da Faculdade de Direito da Universidade do Porto - a.17-18 (2020-2021) - p.117-141
DIREITO CIVIL ABUSO DE DIREITO BOA FÉ SUPREMO TRIBUNAL - Jurisprudência DIREITO DAS SOCIEDADES SOCIEDADE ANÓNIMA
1- The rule prohibiting abuse of rights. 1.1- Description of the subject matter of article 7 CC. 1.2- “Remedies” for abuse. 1.3- Article 7 CC does not establish a universal weighting principle. 1.4- Regarding “qui suo iure utitur naeminem laedit”. 1.5- Article 7 of the Spanish Civil Code allows detailed restrictions to be introduced. 2- Superfluity of the legal percept. 2.1- The “star” of legal rules. 2.2- The rule does not permit deductive inferences. 2.3- Solipsism, interrelation and anti-sociability in the exercise of rights. 3- Relation abuse and specific abuse. 3.1- The limits. 3.2- Illustration of the difference. 3.3- Scenarios of relational abuse. 3.3.1- Inconsistent conduct: estoppel, unfair delay. 3.3.2- Inadmissible past conduct. 3.3.3- Future reversibility. 3.3.4- Useful effect. 3.3.5- De minimis. 4- The holder of the right may make extensive use of it. 4.1- Presentation. 4.2- Illustration. 4.3- The “saturation” of the subject matter 4.4- Illustration of saturation. 4.5- Optional rights to terminate a legal relationship. 4.6- More illustrations of the saturation of rules. 4.7- The deed of right of usufruct in shares that makes the usufructuary's right devoid of substance.