Biblioteca PGR


PP937
Analítico de Periódico



SATZGER, Helmut
Mutual recognition in times of crisis : mutual recognition in crisis? : an analysis of the new jurisprudence on the European Arrest Warrant / Helmut Satzger
European Criminal Law Review, v.8 n.3 (2018), p.317-331


DIREITO COMUNITÁRIO, UNIÃO EUROPEIA, COOPERAÇÃO JUDICIÁRIA EM MATÉRIA PENAL, PRINCÍPIO DO RECONHECIMENTO MÚTUO, MANDADO DE DETENÇÃO EUROPEU, JURISPRUDÊNCIA COMUNITÁRIA

The principle of mutual recognition which was declared to be the cornerstone of judicial cooperation in criminal matters relies on mutual trust between the national authorities involved. The European Union, however, is going through times of crisis - individual Member States deviate from originally common values and convictions, nationalism is on the rise. Under these conditions the existence of mutual trust is difficult to justify. This article tries to analyse whether the recent jurisprudence of the CJEU and some of the national Constitutional Courts reflect these changes. The author favours to uphold the only seemingly outdated “ordre public” proviso as an outlet in order to be prepared to allow exceptions to mutual recognition at least in exceptional cases.